Odds My Soybean Crop Will Mature Before A Killing Frost Hits

The Wisconsin soybean crop is slowly starting to mature, however many growers and crop consultants are still concerned about the risk of frost damage to late planted fields.  In soybean an extended period (several hours) of temperatures 28 degrees F or lower is required to completely kill a soybean plant, though temperatures 32 degrees or less can still damage top growth. Those growers considering the state of their soybean crop and wondering the odds of making it to maturity before significant yield loss occurs must first correctly identify the soybean growth stage

Once the crop growth stage has been determined we can estimate the number of days it will take for your field to reach R7 or physiological maturity.  Across our Arlington and Hancock field sites it has taken 5-8 days to go from R3 to R4, 7-8 days to go from R4 to R5, 10-14 days from R5 to R6 and 14 days from R6 to R7. Note: we have seen crop development expedited the past few weeks due to heat and drought conditions. Next using the three figures below that show the 10th percentile, median, and 90th percentile date when you can expect a freeze event you can estimate the risk of a frost based on your crop growth stage.

For example: If you lived in SW Marathon county there is a 10% chance that a freeze event would have occurred prior to September 11-20, a 50/50 chance that a freeze event would occur prior to September 21-30, and a 90% chance a freeze event would have occurred prior to October 1-10. So if your soybean crop just entered the R5 crop growth stage today 9/7/13 there is a greater than a 50/50 chance that crop won’t make grain based on historical weather data.

Lastly if you are concerned about a freeze event please refer to Table 1 below that provides yield loss estimates of freeze damage by crop crop stage. This may help you decide whether you should risk taking the late planted soybean field as a grain crop or would that field be more valuable as a forage or green manure?

Table 1. Soybean Response to Freeze Damage
Growth Stage
Yield Reduction
R4 – Full pod
70%-80%
R5 – Beginning seed
50%-70%
R6 – Full seed
15%-30%
R7 – Beginning maturity
0%-5%
R8 – Full maturity
0%

Source: Saliba et. at. Kansas State University, 1982


Late Planted Drought Stricken Soybean II: More Valuable as a Forage or Green Manure?

Now that we have checked the label and determined we can legally harvest our soybean crop as a forage now lets consider the calendar for our full suite of options. The average number of days it will take from R6 (full seed) to R7 (beginning maturity) soybean is 15-18 days. If you are in R6 now look at your historic killing frost date and extended weather forecast. If the odds are in your favor roll the dice and cut the beans for grain. If you are not at R6 yet or there is a strong chance of a killing frost in your extended forecast prior to R7 lets realistically consider our options for best utilizing this standing soybean crop.

Option # 1: Soybean haylage considerations

  • What is my realistic tonnage expectations?
    • Late planted drought stricken soybean will yield ~1 to 2 tons of dry matter per acre.
  • What is it going to cost me to harvest and put this crop up?
      • Mowing ($11.45 per hour)
      • Swathing ($13.50 per hour)
      • Haylage (chopping/hour/ ft head width; $12.71)
      • Hauling ($ not listed))
      • Fill silage bags ($10.15 per foot of bag)
  • How should I price this crop?
    • Soybean silage pricing will fall between good quality hay ($233.10 per ton) and poor quality hay ($112.50 per ton); personal communications from P. Hoffman and R Shaver.  Source: FeedVal 2012 predicted dairy feed prices and rankings for August 2013. V.E. Cabrera, P. Hoffman, and R. Shaver.
    • If you were to price the soybean forage based on expected grain yield (assuming the crop would mature) and CBOT then realistic yield levels would range from 12 – 18 bu per acre at $14.35 per bu. Expected forage value range would be $172.20 to $258.30 per acre. 

Option #2: Green manure considerations

  • I am tired of throwing money at this crop……….
    • Though you will save on harvest costs the average cost of a plow down disk operation is $16.05 per acre.
  • How much will I save on next years fertilizer bill?
    • By not harvesting the crop you will not remove the 30# P and 85# K (estimated removal rates of P2O5 and K2O for 15-25 bu per acre soybean grain and straw (A2809)).
    • You may contribute 20-40 pounds of N to next years corn or wheat crop. 
  • I need the feed so this is not an option (please refer back to option #1 above).

Neither of these prove to be particularly attractive options. However I would encourage growers, crop consultants, and nutritionists to weigh the true economical value of each option carefully before proceeding.  

Late Planted Drought Stricken Soybean as a Forage?…Check the Label First

Severe alfalfa winterkill coupled with late soybean plantings followed by dry conditions have growers considering chopping their soybean as a forage. Before you even consider this option make sure you check the label of the pesticides applied to the crop before you grease the chopper.

  • Let’s start with the herbicides first. In short, outside of glyphosate (14 to 25 day, depending upon timing/use) and a handful of pre’s and posts (please refer to Table 3-3 in A3646, Pest Management is WI Field Crops) most soybean herbicides are listed as “not permitted” for forage use. 
  • Next, many common insecticides used for soybean aphid management implicitly state “Do NOT graze or feed treated forage or straw to livestock” (please refer to Table 3-8 in A3646, Pest Management is WI Field Crops) . 
  • Lastly, fungicide labels are as equally exclusive with pre-harvest intervals ranging from 14 days to “Do NOT graze or feed soybean forage or hay” (please refer to Table 3-12 in A3646, Pest Management is WI Field Crops) .

If you somehow pass the gauntlet of “Do not” or “Not Permitted” and the forage value is greater than the grain value then the highest protein and yields are obtained from soybean harvested at the R6 to R7 growth stage. Harvesting soybeans for forage between the R1 and R5 stage will result in a very high quality silage, but dry matter yields will be reduced significantly. Forage quality will be reduced from R5 soybean forward if a conditioning process is used during harvest as conditioning will cause significant seed shattering. For additional information please refer to Soybeans for Hay or Silage.

Have These Recent Cool Temperatures Impacted My 2013 Soybean Crop…In Short Not Yet

Delayed soybean plantings coupled with unseasonably cool temperatures in late July and early August have many growers and crop consultants concerned over the stage and state of the WI soybean crop. Though NASS reports March 1 to August 3 GDU accumulation (base 50 F) to be normal, developmentally the early planted WI soybean crop is tracking ~7 days behind normal. At Arlington WI our early planted High Yield Study is just entering the R5 crop growth stage (seed is 1/8 inch long in the pod at one of the four uppermost nodes on the main stem with a fully developed trifoliolate leaf node).

Image 1. Fourth node pod and bean of R5 plant. Image courtesy of D. Marburger.

Though cool temperatures can reduce photosynthesis and crop growth rate (Table 1), they also extend the number of days in a specific growth stage which allows total dry matter (TDM) to equilibrate thus limiting potential yield loss in early reproductive stages (Board and Kahlon; Seddigh and Jolliff, 1984 a,b).  However if cool conditions (< 50 F) due continue through seedfill or an early frost appears then significant yield loss can occur due to reduced seed size and/or number (Board and Kahlon) (Table 1). In short we are ok to date we just need average temps moving forward and no early frost to finish this crop off.

Table 1. Summary of cold stress effects on soybean physiology, growth, and yield componets. Taken from: Board and Kahlon.

Literature cited:
J.E. Board and C.S. Kahlon. Soybean Yield Formation. What Control it and How it Can be Improved. In Soybean Physiology and Biochemistry. http://www.lsuagcenter.com/NR/rdonlyres/84746337-8BFE-4903-BEB8-420D0D2B7271/82639/InTechSoybean_yield_formation_what_controls_it_and.pdf

Seddigh, M. and Jolliff, G.D. (1984a). Night temperature effects on morphology, phenology, yield and yield components of indeterminate field-grown soybean. Agron J. 76: 824-828. 

Seddigh, M. and Jolliff, G.D. (1984b). Effects of night temperature on dry matter partitioning and seed growth of indeterminate field-grown soybean. Crop Sci. 24: 704-710. 

USDA NASS. Wisconsin Crop Progress. Vol 13. Number 18.

WI Soybean Yield Contest Entry Deadline Extended to (9/1/13)

Delayed planting coupled with wet early season growing conditions across much of Wisconsin has dampened grower enthusiasm to enter the 2013 WI Soybean Yield Contest. Excellent growing conditions over the last several weeks has renewed grower interest. To facilitate this interest we are extending the entry due date to September 1st to enter the contest.  Below please find links for entry forms and rules. Good Luck!!!

High Value Straw and Weedy Wheat…What Do I Do?

Wet fields made spring weed control difficult to impossible in many winter wheat fields, and prolonged wet conditions have encouraged prolific weed growth from large competitive broadleaf weeds like giant ragweed and lambsquarters.  As we approach harvest in southern WI (week of August 21st) growers simply have limited herbicide options for preharvest weed management:

      1. 2,4-D products. There is a 7 day pre-harvest interval with this product. The downside of 2,4-D is you are NOT allowed to feed treated straw to animals. That restriction alone probably leaves just one option…. 

              2. Glyphosate products. There is also a 7 day pre-harvest interval with this product, and it can NOT be applied until the grain is at the hard dough stage (30% moisture or less).  Grain treated with glyphosate at this growth stage should not be used for seed as germination can be significantly lowered. 

                  Some benefits to applying preharvest glyphosate may include desiccation of green weedy plants to enable an easier combine harvest and quicken the ability to bale straw following the grain harvest.  However, drawbacks include a narrow window of application timing ahead of harvest, wheel tracks (if ground applied) will reduce grain yields, and moreover many of the weeds like giant ragweed and lambsquarters will be large and difficult to control.  Thus, consider a preharvest glyphosate application as a last resort because partial control of large weeds will greatly increase selection pressure for glyphosate resistance.  We already have glyphosate-resistant giant ragweed in southern WI , and other broadleaf weeds continue to be a concern. 

                  Shawn Conley and Vince Davis

                  Bloomin Beans, Glyphosate, and Wheel Track Damage

                  The WI soybean crop ranges anywhere from just planted (JP) to beginning flower (R1). As we enter the soybean reproductive growth phase there are a few things to keep in mind. The first is that soybean will produce flowers for ~3 to five weeks, depending upon planting date and environment. During that time soybean will abort anywhere from 20 to 80% of the flowers that they produce. Generally it is the first and last flush of flowers produced that are most likely to be aborted.

                  Mike Bertram a WSA board member reminded me to add the category almost planted (AP).  That’s the treated seed that’s in the drill that will hopefully gets planted if the field dries out this week.  It might end up as forage.

                  R1 soybean growth stage

                  Next, the timing window for glyphosate applications in our early planted soybean is quickly closing. Glyphosate labels indicate that applications can be made through R2 or full flower. The R3 growth stage begins when one of the four top nodes with a fully developed leaf has a 3/16 inch long pod. Applications made after the R3 stage begins are off-label applications. On average it takes ~ 4 days to move from R1 (beginning flower) to R2 (full flower) and ~10 days from R2 to the start of R3 (beginning pod).

                  Last but not least, wheel track damage made from ground applications may start to reduce yield. Sprayer wheel traffic from first flower (R1) through harvest can damage soybean plants and reduce yield (Hanna et al. 2008). Our research suggests that an adequate soybean stand (more than 100,000 plants per acre) planted in late April though mid-May can compensate for wheel tracks made when a field is sprayed at R1. Yield loss can occur, however, when wheel tracks are made at R1 or later in thin soybean stands (less than 100,000 plants per acre) or late planted soybeans. Regardless of stand, plants could not compensate for wheel tracks made at R3 (early pod development) or R5 (early seed development). The average yield loss per acre is based on sprayer boom width (distance between wheel track passes). In our trials yield losses averaged 2.5, 1.9, and 1.3% when sprayer boom widths measured 60, 90, and 120 foot, respectively. Multiple trips along the same wheel tracks did not increase yield loss over the first trip.

                  Spraying soybean at the R1 crop growth stage
                  Wheel track damage to drilled soybean at R1

                  Hanna, S., Conley, S. P., Shaner, G., and Santini, J.  2008.  Fungicide application timing and row spacing effect on soybean canopy penetration and grain yield.  Agronomy Journal: 100:1488-1492. 

                  Deadline Approaching (8/1/13) for Entering the 2013 Wisconsin Soybean Association Yield Contest

                  Late planting and overall wet conditions across many areas in WI have dampened (unfortunate but true pun) the excitement of last year’s yield contest where the 1st place winner in Division 4, Bahr Farms of Belmont grew Trelay 24RR19 and harvested 82.6 bu/a. In Division 3, RnK DeVoe Farms of Monroe won 1stplace with Pioneer 93Y43 at 75.2 bu/a while Division 2 winner, Jerry Koser of Almena achieved 73.7 bu/a from Pioneer 91M10. Last but not least Kloos Acres from Stratford took Division 1 at 61.2 bu/a planting Pioneer 91Y30. If we do get into a normal rainfall pattern there is still significant yield to be gained so as a friendly reminder:

                  • The deadline to enter the 2013 WI Soybean Yield Contest is 8/1/13. 
                  • The objective of this contest is to encourage the development of new and innovative management practices and to show the importance of using sound cultural practices in WI soybean production. 
                  • Districts are based on long term county soybean yield averages (Image 1 below). 
                  • For more information please see the contest brochure or review contest rules and entry form. 

                  Flooded soybean fields starting to show symptoms

                  Scouting our field trials today we noticed an area presenting phytophthora symptoms. Further scouting showed plants were actually dying due to excessive flood injury and soil saturation. These fields have been subjected to nearly 5 inches of rain this week. This specific pocket has been anaerobic for 48 to 76 hours. Couple that with the heat, humidity, and larger crop growth stage (R1) plants are going downhill quickly. For more information on flood damage to soybean please visit www.coolbean.info.

                  Chilton Wheat and FHB (Scab) Prediction Map

                  Just a quick update on what is happening in the WI wheat world today. The Soybean and Small Grain Research Crew was at Chilton today after digging soybean roots at Arlington this morning. Yes soybean does comes first…. At Chilton, powdery mildew was evident in the lower crop canopy, but had yet to move up the stem.

                  Most varieties have wheat heads emerging from the sheath. A couple early wheat varieties had a few heads starting to flower. However the majority of flowering at our Chilton site should take place late this week into the weekend.

                  The southern 1/3 of the state has or is experiencing wheat flowering now (Damon Smith applied the FHB fungicides today at Arlington). Below please see a risk map regarding today’s risk for FHB. West central WI is located in the medium to high risk zone so please scout accordingly. Remember risk is associated with weather conditions and crop growth stage. Fungicide options for FHB are found at Management of Small Grain Diseases Fungicide Efficacy for Control of Wheat Diseases.

                  For more information on FHB please visit